- 2023 — Cat in a McCaffrey Suit
- 2022 — Cat in a COOPER Suit
- 2021 — Cat in a GEQBUS Suit
- 2020 — CatinaCovidSuit
- 2019 — AceBoogie&TheCatPack
- 2018 — CatInAJoeySuit
- 2017 — CatInAJoeySuit
- 2016 — Cat In A Wet Suit
- 2015 — Cat In A Wet Suit
- 2014 — Cat In A Wet Suit
- 2013 — Cat In A Wet Suit
- 2012 — Cat In A Wet Suit
- 2011 — Immaculate Deception
- 2010 — Jack Plexico
- 2009 — Chillllllld Pleaseee
- 2008 — Boo Boo Heads
- 2007 — Boo Boo Heads
- 2006 — J-Plex
- Jack
All-Time What If!?!?!
12th place (4-10-0)
All-Time What If!?!?! finished the 2024 season in 12th place after a regular season 12th place finish with 1,216.58 points and a 4-10-0 record. All-Time What If!?!?! made 17 roster moves throughout the season.
| Week 1 |
All-Time What If!?!?! 59.42 | L |
| Intestino Clandestino 61.82 | ||
| Week 2 |
All-Time What If!?!?! 76.60 | L |
| Green Goblins 83.34 | ||
| Week 3 |
All-Time What If!?!?! 86.16 | L |
| ᕦ⊙෴⊙ᕤ 109.04 | ||
| Week 4 |
All-Time What If!?!?! 85.82 | L |
| Patrick's Pirates 101.38 | ||
| Week 5 |
All-Time What If!?!?! 84.12 | L |
| Fat Pickles 117.08 | ||
| Week 6 |
All-Time What If!?!?! 91.16 | L |
| Llunsford's Llamas 112.02 | ||
| Week 7 |
All-Time What If!?!?! 88.44 | L |
| Refrigerator Raiders 120.74 | ||
| Week 8 |
All-Time What If!?!?! 102.80 | W |
| The Pope Maybe in Rome 93.82 | ||
| Week 9 |
All-Time What If!?!?! 103.50 | L |
| Literally 103.80 | ||
| Week 10 |
All-Time What If!?!?! 82.18 | W |
| Token Females 77.28 | ||
| Week 11 |
All-Time What If!?!?! 72.04 | W |
| The Keyshawn Johnsons 71.08 | ||
| Week 12 |
All-Time What If!?!?! 103.20 | W |
| Intestino Clandestino 68.06 | ||
| Week 13 |
All-Time What If!?!?! 84.84 | L |
| Green Goblins 135.94 | ||
| Week 14 |
All-Time What If!?!?! 96.30 | L |
| ᕦ⊙෴⊙ᕤ 115.06 | ||
| Consolation | ||
| Week 15 |
All-Time What If!?!?! 0.00 | |
| ᕦ⊙෴⊙ᕤ 0.00 | ||