- 2016 — Can't Stump The Joey
- 2015 — Sterile Technique
- 2014 — Poop on a Stick
- 2013 — West Coast Defence
- 2012 — States Rights
- 2011 — Poo Pride
- 2010 — Radon
- 2009 — The Dirty Hippies
- 2008 — Bullet Bill
- 2007 — PincheGringoBambinos
- 2006 — The Rockets
- Joey
- 2018 — The Lotus Eaters
- 2019 — The Lotus Eaters
- 2020 — A Family of Deer
- 2021 — The Atlanta Braves World Serie
- 2022 — UnitedFC
- 2023 — The Blue Dawgs
- 2024 — The Keyshawn Johnsons
Order 69
11th place (4-10-0)
Order 69 finished the 2017 season in 11th place after a regular season 11th place finish with 1,121.30 points and a 4-10-0 record. Order 69 drafted 5th and made 19 roster moves throughout the season.
| Week 1 |
Order 69 81.52 | L |
| Refrigerator Raiders 86.22 | ||
| Week 2 |
Order 69 86.62 | W |
| DEF IN CONTENTION 84.38 | ||
| Week 3 |
Order 69 57.60 | L |
| Crooked Joey 93.12 | ||
| Week 4 |
Order 69 58.64 | L |
| Llunsford's Llamas 106.18 | ||
| Week 5 |
Order 69 67.36 | L |
| Joey Martin's Heroes 87.32 | ||
| Week 6 |
Order 69 52.28 | L |
| NAH BRO 114.60 | ||
| Week 7 |
Order 69 96.82 | L |
| ♘ Chess 114.76 | ||
| Week 8 |
Order 69 93.64 | W |
| DEF NOT LAST 70.88 | ||
| Week 9 |
Order 69 76.86 | L |
| ———————————————— 95.92 | ||
| Week 10 |
Order 69 56.10 | L |
| CatInAJoeySuit 88.36 | ||
| Week 11 |
Order 69 86.92 | W |
| Joey Martin.com 72.30 | ||
| Week 12 |
Order 69 118.88 | W |
| Refrigerator Raiders 104.64 | ||
| Week 13 |
Order 69 106.72 | L |
| DEF IN CONTENTION 119.42 | ||
| Week 14 |
Order 69 81.34 | L |
| Crooked Joey 99.82 | ||